Great Western Buildings Lawsuit: Complete guide 2024

Great Western Buildings Lawsuit: Complete guide 2024

In the late 1980s and early 1990s, Great Western Buildings sold many pre-built steel buildings yearly to people nationwide. Folks liked how easy the kit buildings were to put together. They would use the buildings for their homes, barns, workshops, and more. But soon, many folks noticed issues with their steel buildings

Even though the buildings were just a few years old, the steel was already rusting and eroding too quickly. Owners saw leaks, problems with the framing, and expensive repairs needed so soon. They thought this shouldn’t be happening, as their buildings were brand new just a few years ago.

next exam tak

Great Western Building Systems Lawsuit

This case involves a construction company called Great Western Building Systems, LLC, facing a class-action lawsuit filed in 2022. The lawsuit alleges that the company used defective materials and construction methods in many of its buildings, leading to serious safety and health risks for homeowners and businesses.

next exam tak

Some specific claims against Great Western Buildings Lawsuite include

  • Using drywall containing dangerous levels of sulphur dioxide
  • Installing insulation that contained Mold and asbestos
  • Using windows that were not adequately sealed and leaked air and water
  • These alleged defects have reportedly caused a range of problems, including:
  • Structural damage to buildings
  • Respiratory problems, skin irritation, and cancer in residents
  • Financial losses for homeowners and businesses due to repairs and property devaluation
  • The lawsuit is still pending, and it is too early to say the outcome. However, if the plaintiffs are successful, it could result in significant financial compensation for those whom Great Western Buildings’ construction practices have harmed.
  • Image of Gavel banging on Law bench Opens in a new window

The Great Western Building Lawsuit (Mumbai)

This lawsuit dates back to the 19th century and involves a historic building called the Great Western Building in Mumbai, India. The building has served various purposes throughout history, including being a governor’s residence, an admiralty house, and a hotel.

In 1883, the building was converted into the Great Western Hotel. A new five-story wing was added in the early 1890s. However, the hotel eventually closed, and the rooms were subdivided for rental purposes. The lawsuit relates to a dispute over these subdivided units’ ownership and occupancy rights. The details of the case are complex and involve various legal issues.

Next exam tak

Customer Complaints Emerge

The first signs of trouble emerged in the early 1990s as more and more frustrated Great Western building owners began documenting issues. Customers reported that the galvanized steel used in the frames and wall panels seemed to be rusting and corroding much faster than it should. Within 5-10 years, unsightly rust stains and holes were visible. Even worse, the corrosion was causing beams and panels to buckle or break loose, threatening the integrity of the entire structure.

Next exam tak

Class Action Lawsuit Filed

In 1996, Colorado resident Ray Dolin- whose Great Western barn had developed serious rust problems after six years- took legal action. He filed a class action lawsuit against the company for himself and the thousands of other disgruntled owners

The complaint alleged that Great Western knew or should have known that their steel choice and welding techniques were inadequate and would lead to premature corrosion. It claimed the company was negligent and breached the implied warranty that the buildings would last a reasonable lifespan before needing repairs.

Great Western Buildings Lawsuit Denies Fault

Great Western denied any wrongdoing and fought the allegations vigorously. They claimed the steel and welds met industry standards and that other factors like harsh weather or improper assembly could be to blame for owners’ issues. However, plaintiffs could present evidence that similar steel buildings from different manufacturers were not experiencing problems on the same scale. Engineers also found widespread faults in Great Western’s welding

Trial and Ruling

After several years of legal proceedings, the case went to trial in Colorado. In November 2000, the jury sided with the plaintiffs, ruling that Great Western was negligent in their choice of steel, quality control, and assembly methods. A few months later, in 2001, the Colorado Supreme Court upheld the jury’s verdict, marking one of the largest class action settlements in state history.

next exam tak

Resolution and Impact

Great Western ultimately agreed to pay up to $50 million to cover repairs or replacements for the 20,000 affected building owners. While not all claims were fully reimbursed, it provided much-needed relief

The case set an important precedent that manufacturers have an implied warranty that structures will last for a reasonable period before costly defects arise. It was a significant victory for consumer protection laws regarding prefabricated building quality.

A few other notable class action lawsuits that have impacted the construction industry:

  1. Chinese Drywall Class Action: Thousands of homes built between 2001 and 2008 used defective imported drywall that emitted corrosive gases, damaging appliances, pipes, and metals. Lawsuits against manufacturers in China are still ongoing.
  2. Polybutylene Plumbing Class Action: Defects in polybutylene pipes caused them to leak prematurely in an estimated 1 million homes built in the 1980s-90s and settled in 1995 for $950 million.
  3. Framing Defects Lawsuit Against Toll Brothers: Thousands of homeowners alleged builder Toll Brothers used inadequate materials and techniques, leading to structural issues. She was settled in 2009 for $11 million.
  4. Dryvit Stucco Siding Class Action: Cracks and leaks were reported in structures sided with Dryvit’s synthetic stucco product and settled in 2008 for $305 million after evidence it absorbed water.
  5. TrusJoist Floor System Defects Lawsuit: Weyerhaeuser’s TJI floor joists experienced mold or rot problems. They were settled for $170 million in 2007 to repair 35,000 homes.
  6. Tile Roof Defects Lawsuit Against GAF: CertainTeed and MFM Building Products settled separate lawsuits over premature shingle breakdown and leaks for $68 million and $9 million, respectively.

These lawsuits helped shape modern building codes while providing reimbursement to homeowners. They also showed construction product quality needs oversight to prevent costly structural or health issues
For related techktimes articles Click here

Beyond the Headlines:

These lawsuits aren’t mere statistics. They represent lives upended, families displaced, and livelihoods threatened. Homeowners grapple with crumbling walls and health anxieties, businesses struggle with costly repairs and relocation, and individuals fight for compensation and recognition of their pain.

A Trail of Legal Tangled Vines:

Each case weaves a complex narrative of expert testimony clashing overbuilding codes, contractors pointing fingers, and financial damages stacking up like dominoes. Years of litigation inch forward, leaving a trail of uncertainty and frustration in their wake.

The Fallout: Justice Sought, Reputation Tarnished:

The lawsuits damaged Great Western’s reputation. Folks used to trust them entirely but now had doubts. Could they rely on Significant Western buildings? People watched them closely, leaving the company with an uphill battle to regain trust. It wouldn’t be easy to show people they make quality structures again. Great Western had their work cut out to fix how folks saw them after the problems.

A Call for Change:

These lawsuits brought up important questions. How can people make buildings better? What oversight is needed? And how responsible should companies be? Great Western’s story shows we must be careful. Quality and safety should come before all else

The story isn’t over yet. More court cases are still happening. And what will become of the Great Western is unclear. But one thing is clear – what happened here will cause significant changes. It will make construction workers think harder about how we design and oversee projects and ensure companies are accountable when things go wrong. These legal battles will keep shaping how whole communities are built for years.

Next exam tak

Lessons Learned

The Great Western Buildings lawsuit showed that cutting corners on materials and construction practices can backfire tremendously. While the company is no longer in business today, their experience is a cautionary tale. Building owners also learned to be wary of premature corrosion claims or widespread issues as potential red flags of an underlying defect. Overall, it highlighted the importance of quality control standards within the prefab structures industry.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *